If I had a dollar for every time someone asked me “which sweetener should I use?” — well, I’d have enough to buy a very large bag of organic allulose. 😄
So let’s settle this once and for all. Here’s my honest, research-backed breakdown of the three most popular natural sweeteners right now: monk fruit, stevia, and allulose.
The good news first: all three are far better than regular sugar. None of them spike your blood sugar meaningfully, and all have solid safety track records. But they’re not identical — and the differences matter depending on your goals.
🌿 STEVIA
Best for: Budget-friendly, everyday use
Stevia comes from the leaves of the Stevia rebaudiana plant and is 200–400x sweeter than sugar, so a tiny amount goes a long way. It’s zero-calorie, non-glycemic, and has one of the longest safety records of any natural sweetener.
The catch? Many people notice a bitter or slightly metallic aftertaste — especially in beverages like coffee or in frozen desserts. It’s less noticeable in baked goods.
One thing worth knowing: not all stevia is created equal. Look for “Reb M” on the label if you want a cleaner, less bitter taste. “Reb A” is cheaper and more common, but it’s the one most likely to leave that aftertaste.
🍈 MONK FRUIT
Best for: Zero-calorie sweetening with a cleaner taste
Monk fruit gets its sweetness from compounds called mogrosides, which also happen to have antioxidant properties and may support healthy metabolism. It has a pleasantly clean, slightly fruity sweetness — and most people find it tastes better than stevia.
Here’s the thing I always tell my readers: flip the bag over and read the ingredient list. Most “monk fruit sweeteners” on the shelf are actually 99% erythritol with just a trace of monk fruit added. This matters because recent research (2023 and a 2025 follow-up) has raised some questions about erythritol and cardiovascular health. The research is still evolving, but it’s worth being aware of.
If you want pure monk fruit, look for products where it’s the primary or only ingredient — expect to pay more, but a little goes a very long way.
🍬 ALLULOSE
Best for: Baking, cooking, and overall metabolic health
Allulose is the newcomer that’s been quietly winning over nutrition researchers. It’s a rare sugar found naturally in figs and raisins that your body absorbs but doesn’t metabolize for energy — so it provides almost no calories and has virtually no impact on blood sugar. Some studies even suggest it may slightly blunt blood sugar spikes after meals, which is a meaningful benefit.
What makes allulose stand out is that it actually behaves like sugar in the kitchen. It caramelizes, browns, adds moisture, and gives baked goods the right texture. Stevia and monk fruit simply can’t do this.
The downsides: it’s pricier than the others, harder to find (especially outside the US), and not yet approved in Canada or the EU.
⚖️ SO WHICH IS BEST?
Honestly, the answer depends on what you’re using it for:
• For everyday sweetening (coffee, tea, smoothies): Monk fruit (pure extract or blended with allulose) or Reb M stevia
• For baking and cooking: Allulose is the clear winner
• For tight budgets: Stevia (Reb M if possible)
• For blood sugar support: Allulose has the edge
And regardless of which you choose — always check the ingredient list for erythritol as a filler, and watch for additives like maltodextrin, which can actually spike blood sugar despite being in a “zero-sugar” product.
🌱 IS ORGANIC WORTH IT?
For these sweeteners specifically, the organic label matters less than you might think. The bigger wins come from choosing a clean ingredient list (no erythritol fillers, no maltodextrin) over paying a premium for organic certification.
That said, organic stevia and monk fruit can be slightly preferable since they’re plant-derived and may involve fewer chemical inputs during processing. For allulose — made via fermentation — the organic distinction is more marginal.
Bottom line: read the ingredients first. Organic second. If you’d like a nutrition consultation, please email me amahl@vhhealth.com. Enjoy more general information on Instagram from @vh_health.com
van halsema pilates 